04.26.07
What I Deny
As I’ve said before, I do not deny the existence of God, but there are some things that I do deny. Many of them actually assume that God exists, so what I mean then is that “if there is a God, I deny that he is like x.”
Anyway.
I deny the existence of hell. That an even marginally good god would damn people to eternal punishment and torture for finite sins committed in virtual ignorance is absolutely preposterous. That some people do believe this makes my mind boggle.
I deny the infallibility of the Bible (or any other religious text), of human religious leaders, of religions, and of philosophies. The claim of infallibility is unbelievably arrogant, and reality usually shows the truth.
I deny the existence of Fossil-Hiding God. What I mean by that is that I deny that God would create a world that looked like he didn’t create it as some kind of test of faith. I deny that God would say x, and then purposely hide all evidence of x and in fact plant all kinds of counterevidence against x. “Test us,” my eye.
I deny the existence of any one “chosen people.” I deny an ethnocentric God.
I deny that morality is based on God’s decree. I deny that the only line between moral and immoral is the whim of deity. I deny a moral system that is ultimately based on “because I said so.” That’s elementary school morality. God is certainly better than that, if he indeed exists. And we have the potential to be better than that, and I hardly believe that God simply wants us to behave according to the lowest common denominator. At the very least, it would make God an arbitrary and capricious God, and that takes me to two sub-denials:
I deny arbitrary commandments, i.e., things that are not inherently, intuitively immoral. This is of course a subset of the above denial, because the only thing that makes homosexuality immoral, for example, is “God said so.” Or tea and coffee in Mormonism. Being harmful to people doesn’t naturally equal immoral (otherwise getting in a car would be immoral), and the only thing that would make the Word of Wisdom a moral issue would be the fact that God said do. And I deny that God ever said such a thing.
I deny an arbitrary God. If God exists, he certainly doesn’t predestine some people for heaven and some for hell. That’s cruel capriciousness. Being the supreme being doesn’t mean he can just do whatever he wants, and if it does, then I deny the existence of a God who would just do whatever he wanted even if he could.
That’s all I can think of. There are more nit-picky things I deny, but those are specific religious doctrines that I reject, as opposed to these kinds of overarching universal denials.
Alexei said,
April 26, 2007 at 3:18 pm
Loved the post! Very coherently well put, thank you. I know you have touched upon Neo-Paganism, but with a little help you may as well be pagan with such outlook
pantlessjohnny said,
April 26, 2007 at 6:18 pm
So did you pass your finals?
Kullervo said,
April 26, 2007 at 6:35 pm
Not yet!
My last day of class was today. My finals start next week, and run for two weeks.
Kullervo said,
April 26, 2007 at 7:17 pm
Alexei, if you’re right, then Jeff Lilly is pretty persuasive when he says that Paganism is a far more intuitive religion.
Anubys said,
April 27, 2007 at 1:15 am
Man I don’t even know where to start. This post was RIGHT ON. You’ve just said and summed up so many ideas I’ve had bouncing around in my head for the past year or so. Thank you for organizing MY HEAD.
peace.
Kullervo said,
April 27, 2007 at 5:46 am
Anytime!
randy said,
April 28, 2007 at 6:45 am
What fossil-hiding God? Is He the one who helps find lost car keys while ignoring the plight of people in hellholes like Darfur? Also, are you one of them peoples what’s for women havin’ more than one piercing per ear?
mel said,
April 28, 2007 at 10:08 am
Thank you, Kullervo. I have been sustained by your testimony.
I’d like to say that I too deny these things. And I would add: I deny that any god worth adoration would require my unthinking, unquestioning obedience as a measure of my worth.
And, I do deny that there is a god. Because god is defined by human beings. Whatever else there is out there, if it does not match the human definition of god, is something else entirely.